Police Chief Talks about the Effects of AB.109 and Prop. 47 on City of Escondido,California! BY JASON MILLER


The Escondido Police & Fire Headquarters located on North Centre City Parkway in Escondido,CA. Photo By Jason Miller


In 2011 the state of California embarked on a “grand experiment” with a massive downsizing of the state’s prisons. How did this happen; according to Katy Grimes, Senior Correspondent at The CA Flash Report says that in 2009 a federal panel of three judges ordered that the state of CA had to reduce its prison population by 25 percent within two years which added up to about forty-six thousand within that period. The state appealed it to the US Supreme Court which then upheld the mandate in May of 2011 in a 5-4 decision. Writing the dissenting opinion was the late Supreme Court Justice Antonia Scalia who said it was quote: “perhaps most radical injunction issued by a court in our nation’s history”. So the state of California’s State Assembly passed AB 109 also know as “prison realignment” which was supposed to be a legislative vehicle to comply with the court’s orders to reduce the state’s prison population. Grimes states that instead of reducing the population it caused a controversial program known as “realignment,” whereby “newly convicted low-level offenders without current or prior serious or violent offenses stay in a county jail to serve their sentence.” Also questioned were the “split sentences” under AB 109’s mandate post-release community supervision as part of the effort to rehabilitate offenders with community-based programs once a criminal is released from custody. But critics of AB 109 found that there is little or no supervision of these criminals. So in reality, it has shifted high-risk and ultra-high-risk offenders, because the law ignores the offender’s prior criminal history, including serious and violent offenses, this according to sheriffs around the state.

Fast forward to November of 2014 Prop. 47 gets passed by the voters. The passing of this proposition caused crime to rise according to recent local data that shows crime rising last year. The state reduced prison time for sex offenders and released them across the state which has caused the most damage on the street increasing violent crime in the state according to Grimes. She further states that prior to the passage of Prop. 47 that the Public Policy Institute reported that California’s violent crime rate of 422 per 100,00 residents was higher than the national rate of 387 and was 16th in the US. In the year 2013 59% of violent crimes in California were aggravated assaults, 35 percent were robberies, 5 percent were rapes and 1 percent homicides.


Escondido’s Chief of Police Craig Carter; Photo By Jason Miller


The Miller News Service interviewed Police Chief Craig Carter who has been in charge of Escondido’s Police Department going on three years and asked him about these numbers as well as how this is affecting the running of his department. He says what concerns him the most is the prisoners who are released without probation or parole. The best way to handle it Chief Carter says is to deal with it by making sure to notify the Probation or Parole Departments when there is a violation of AB. 109 which requires additional charges. According to Chief Carter property crime was up 12% in Escondido last year, violent crime up 3.3% and theft up 15%. Carter says it will continue to go up in 2016 and needs to be addressed.

On Prop. 47 Chief Carter says the dynamics have changed on how his department responds to drug and theft case’s; he says criminals in those categories have realized that they commit the same crime many times knowing that they will not be held accountable as they have in the past before Prop.47 when it was a felony. He did, however, say that that the drug courts have picked back up since the initial passing of Prop.47. The Chief said adjustments to city law have had to be made since the legalization of medical marijuana; when driving under the influence-high or in the possession of marijuana Chief Carter says they will take it as far as his department can when it comes to criminal prosecution.

When it comes to the rape and gun law portions of Prop.47 or AB 109 Chief Carter told me that there is or will be clean up language in the CA. state legislator to change those parts of the law from misdemeanors back to felonies. When I asked the chief if it was frustrating for his officers; he said there is frustration but it is his job to keep his officers focused and to be an advocate for change in his department. Chief Carter also takes frequent trips up to Sacramento to help incite that change.

Special Thanks to Katy Grimes, Special Corespondent for the CA Flash Report for the latest CA. crime statics for this story.

© 2017 Miller News Service

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s